Just a believed: if people are just blindly substituting a Ched 209 for the W209, probably they've entered into an about tension circumstance That may exacerbate the piercing situation.
There is certainly only 1 way to get an precise respond to towards your question in lieu of speculations and conjectures: cautiously assemble 10 equivalent shells working with Every primer and send out them to your ballistics lab such as the one particular at Downrange Mfg.
It really is kinda like individuals that make use of a slower burning powder saying to obtain minimized recoil than a more rapidly burning powder, Regardless of both loads becoming the exact same velocity and ejecta weight. It must be These super duper recoil minimizing wads.
This is often my viewpoint also. You've plenty of "headroom" on stress for the primer substitution. Also, because you already hold the go ahead from Alliant to sub within the Win primer for the Rem, Will probably be Alright to sub from the Cheddite primer as (I believe) it can be "cooler" than the Get primer.
The load I'm applying is not posted by Alliant, as they do not publish A lot data 209 muzzleloader primer for Remington hulls and Winchester primers. I did, nonetheless, e-mail them, plus they stated that within the force the Rem primer/Rem hull the recipe requires, they felt it absolutely was Safe and sound. Listed here are the details:
The powder corporations need to just Cease publishing real "PSI" data (since they can't Handle it), and just publish cost body weight "vary" and velocity "array" data, and just omit publish all "tension" data altogether. I feel You will find there's great deal of people who agree using this.
I think that All of this next guessing and tests of previously published data is building folks to chase 'ghosts'.
A brand new question which has been raised is How come K80 firing pins get toasted by Cheddite primers although my Huglu Turk manufactured DeHann eats them for lunch? Spring pressure? Condition with the pins?
WARNING – primers 1000 count Winchester may possibly explode if subjected to affect, shock, or intensive warmth. Keep in unique manufacturing facility container only. Primers in bulk are capable of mass explosion. Usually do not use primer feed products for reloading. one hundred pack.
"A Liberal is someone who does not care Whatever you do, so long as It is mandatory". - Charles Krauthammer
Please comprehend, Regardless how this might look, That is an issue caused at deprime not reprime. For those who carry on down the 'how arrive this only transpires with Winchester primers rather than Cheddite primers' highway, you will never solve the issue.
I determine what you posted. I can browse. I do not use Alliant items nor do I substitute Cheddite 209 primers for Winchester 209 primers. So I won't be contacting Alliant to talk with Ben.
I believe the OP addressed the why in his article. He was curious whether or not what "Absolutely everyone already is aware of" is really suitable or not.
